Tags
Charlie Murphy, Clayton Cubitt, female orgasm, Jane Eyre on Page and Screen, Robertson Davies, vibrators
Trust me to discover something cool online by reading a paper mag. But it was in Vanity Fair that I read about photographer/director Clayton Cubitt and his project “Hysterical Literature,” which features women reading favorite books aloud while being erotically stimulated by Cubitt’s unseen female “assistant” (his partner Katie James).
Toni Bentley, author of The Surrender: An Erotic Memoir, wrote about her experience as one of Cubitt’s subjects. The women who participate choose their own clothes and makeup, as well as their reading matter (in Toni’s case, Henry James’s Portrait of a Lady). They are filmed in black and white, sitting at a small, plain desk. At first the women read calmly, but after a page or two, they begin to smile at odd moments and to pause unexpectedly. Their breathing speeds up, and their fingers move restlessly over the book. Their voices break down at points, then they resolutely continue. Eventually, anywhere between four and twelve minutes from the start of the video, each one has an unmistakable orgasm.

Subjects in the “Hysterical Literature” series by Clayton Cubitt. Photo from Vanity Fair. The highlighted photos are of Toni.
Someone should have thought of this a long time ago. It’s simple, but brilliant in so many ways, as a commentary on the relationship between literary pleasure and libido, as an exploration of female sexuality in the modern world, as an antidote to the usual media depiction of women as idealized collections of body parts. These women are fully clothed, clearly not acting, and individuals with distinct personalities. The videos are profound examples of portraiture. They’re also amusing, witty and erotic. And they raise certain questions. I found myself wondering whether men even find this kind of material sexy. After all, real female orgasm generates very little interest in the porn world (or so far as I can tell, in any other area of media, haute literature or popular culture). Even “women’s fiction” tends to distort the picture with unrealistic depictions of vaginal orgasm. Of course, porn has plenty of women faking it. But everyone knows they are faking it.
Another question was how Mister Cubitt (actually Katie the assistant) is able to produce such reliable and (relatively) speedy orgasms. Not surprisingly, it’s because Katie is down there using a Hitachi Magic Wand, also known as “the paintbrush” or “Big Buzzy,” a vibrator so famous that it has its own Wikipedia article. Toni Bentley told Katie that she was a Hitachi virgin, never having used a vibrator.
I never really understood the point of vibrators, particularly if there was an able-bodied man around– so she offered to touch the side of my knee with the wand before filming as a preview. Holy Mary Mother of God.
That’s right, Toni. A vibrator is not a substitute for something else. It is its own unique thing, like miso or Jon Stewart. Admittedly the Hitachi is a bit intimidating (and has a power cord!), but there are other choices. Gentlemen, if you have not yet added one of these little gems to your sexual arsenal, hie thee to http://www.adamandeve.com. And yes, there’s an app for it.

Left, the Cat’s Paw. Right, the Lelo, which looks like the Spaceship of the Imagination from Cosmos…
The other burning question this article raised for me is of course: What would I read? There are several possible approaches.
The first thing I thought of was Jane Eyre (“You examine me, Miss Eyre. Do you think me handsome?”… )
But that’s too obvious, isn’t it? Wouldn’t it be better to choose something not overtly sexy, so as to create a pleasing contrast between what is taking place above the neutral grey desk and below it? I might pick one of my old favorites like I, Claudius by Robert Graves, A Clockwork Orange (which was indeed selected by Cubitt’s subject Amanda) or anything by Robertson Davies.
Then again, I might be a bit more sly than that. Nabokov’s Ada, for example, or Sigmund Freud’s Studies on Hysteria.
How could I pass up the opportunity to read about food whilst being pleasured? Brillat-Savarin’s The Physiology of Taste, or Transcendental Gastronomy. Anything by M. F. K. Fisher (also the able translator of Brillat-Savarin). Julia Child’s Mastering the Art of French Cooking.
Finally, it would be delightful to select a comic novel. Wodehouse, David Lodge, Stella Gibbons’s Cold Comfort Farm. The possibilities are endless.
The French have an expression for it, la petite mort. And who doesn’t want to die laughing?
You are on form today, aren’t you?? 🙂
Heh, heh. And for my next trick, I’ll learn how to say “magic wand” in six languages…
Here it is in Greek: μαγικό ραβδί ( magico rav-thee)
Hahaha! The rhabdos of Hermes maybe 🙂 He is known for his statues “with wand.”
Just don’t try that in a Portuguese supermarket…
Hahahaha! I’ll be sure to ask for a magic wand with batteries on the side.
Wow. When I first read your post I thought – dubious project, possibly objectifiying, counterproductive. Ok, but I had to see it for myself. And boy, I found this really touching! This is so not faked but real, and there is nothing bad taste about it. It’s a raw look at female orgasm without the distraction of nudity. I read the notes by “Solé” and was struck by how “freeing” she found participation in this. Interesting thought. In any case, thanks for posting about this. There is not enough serious, valid commentary on female orgasm out there, and this one deserves to be seen. (PS – that magic wand, though…)
Thanks for the comments Guylty! What fascinates me most is the idea of portraiture inherent in this, how it shows something unique about each subject, and yet shows what each of them has in common as a woman.
Most excellent intel!
Thanks!
I read about this project some time ago. Given the position Katie the assistant had to assume with each participant I imagine her manipulating the magic wand under a “sedia stercoraria” without shouting “Duos habet et bene pendentes” afterwards, of course.
I would like to add a Rochester to your gallery (Toby Stephens). I thank tv and film industry for insisting in portraying Rochesters who are by far more beautiful than the original
ahhh, the pic looks familiar and now i am wondering if i saw this Jane Eyre, i love the book but the film versions even more 🙂 I have to admit since Darcy is out of the picture this is my secret wish for a period drama for R…. sigh
Oooh, Armitage as Rochester? He is almost too handsome, but I can definitely see him in the role. Why can’t he play Darcy? I would love that.
me too, but these days Tv /film tends to go for younger and younger actors to play that part and last versions are a bit too recent, don’t think there would be another for another 5 years and he’d be past it for TV 😦 LOL i don’t think he is that handsome 🙂 Never did actually, attractive yes, but that is different. I think he can look very harsh, angular if he so chooses, his face seems to change a lot with the roles he embodies 🙂 I have more trouble thinking that they would have to obscure his eyes in the end.. but hm, i just don’t see the industry casting him as a romantic lead anytime soon 😦
It perplexes me that they don’t think of RA as a romantic lead. But the same thing happened to Mr. H. He had that one tiny window where he played Rochester and Wentworth, but that was the end of it. Even with those roles, a lot of women couldn’t get past his looks. Maybe that is why I enjoy Richard so much, because I can’t abide a pretty boy. Well, maybe a Brad Pitt every now and then. And Colin Firth is OK with me 🙂
i fear that ship sailed into harbour with Thornton and sailed out with Thorin… There may not have been a love story in it but he certainly was a romantic lead 🙂 I fear love stories of the romantic kind are not so much his cup of tea and certainly not what he gets asked to do… I have this vision of Tristan in my head, but it will never happen. yeah, Pitt is ok but Firth much better 🙂 Funny enough he keeps playing the romantic lead, even if the movie itself is very quirky. I just watched Magic in the Moonlight the other day and loved it 🙂 He’ll keep doing all sorts i suspect, also because he’d not much done the action figure hero. R has really got that going and somehow i feel more of those will come his way for quite a while longer and not much of the romantic stuff. I am not that fussed, more fussed about more live theatre tbh 😉
Yes, they will keep casting him as an action hero. He’s got a great body, and the roughness of his looks fits with that. He could go on for a long time, like Liam Neeson 🙂 But I’m with you. Let’s get him back on the stage!!
I loved “Magic in the Moonlight.” Haven’t seen the new Woody Allen film, but I want to. I like Joaquin Phoenix. There’s another unusual looking, gorgeous man!
ditto, the other reason of my fascination with the Gladiator 😉 though i have seen him in many other films 😉
Oh yes, he was wonderful in “Gladiator.”
LOL. A whole gallery of Pope Joans! And not a testicle in the room unless we count Mister Cubitt. I think he does remain in the room whilst filming.
Thank you for the lovely addition. It is true, all the Rochesters seem suspiciously handsome, which is one reason I prefer the version with my own beau-laid Mr. H. 🙂
I have to admit, I’m skeptical I could achieve orgasm while reading a book to a camera. I can understand the voyeuristic elements at play, but the reading out loud part would definitely be distracting. And the camera, for me, would be distracting too…I’d be too self-conscious.
Yes, I think I would be very self-conscious too. Especially given that Katie and Clayton would be strangers to me. I wonder if they have had any “failures” where the person couldn’t relax enough to get there. That would be interesting too. I think he began with people he knew were on the exhibitionistic side, like Stoya who is actually a porn star. But then he started to expand his pool of subjects.
I agree, it would be interesting to see the failures. Maybe even more interesting in a way.
I can see how finding exhibitionists would make the task a lot easier…but then there’s all the variations of exhibitionism. Cameras would not be cool for me. But porn stars are used to that.
It must have been quite a novelty for Stoya to keep her clothes on 😀
I can only do one thing at a time 🙂
LOL! It can’t hurt to give the task at hand one’s full attention 🙂
Interesting project, i wonder if the readers picked their books with the experience in mind or just went for their favourites 🙂 Also interesting what wins out or how the mind reading the book interacts with the sensory challenges 🙂 It’s nicely filmed.
Lelo, they are said to be very high end and quality products, certainly looks like it, the techie is certainly tempted :-p What on earth is that pink furry thing.. LOL
The app…. Samungs are more powerful than iphones, just sayin 😉
Mr Rochester, oh yes… i love the book and made every effort to see any filmed version that i bumped into, certainly saw those 3, last one is Fassbander, isn’t it? It’s my last hope for a period piece i really like for Mr A… i fear my hopes there are in vain.
By they way, i always bump into the most interesting of your old articles via the automatic suggestions, like the one on Alexander Skarsgard! And guess what i bumped into today: http://www.standard.co.uk/lifestyle/london-life/alexander-skarsgrd-sexism-is-a-big-problem-in-hollywood-10423577.html
Interesting new projects and interesting articles about him, haven’t watched True Blood myself but he sounds so much like the 2 Swedes i knew/know. They even look a lot like him, both were very tall and it probably is a common way of thinking, certainly about women. Both Peder and Henrik were great friends and probably the men i’ve met who’ve been most comfortable and almost in-tune with women. I don’t know if it is a thing of modern Nordic culture or more Swedish (but i’ve seen Danes with very similar ways of thinking and more importantly, acting) but there was a sense of support, understanding and comfort that came naturally and with no effort, it just was. The least macho culture i encountered in men, while at the same time being very manly.
Anyway, just wanted to share that article with you, i’ll need to look out for that film.
I can vouch for the high quality of the Lelo 🙂 I don’t have a cats paw but I did write a buzzing bee cat toy into one of my stories!
And yes, there are complaints that the iPhone app is no good because it just doesn’t have enough power. No doubt it really drains the battery too!
Fassy made a good Rochester. I probably never met a Rochester I didn’t like. Even William Hurt, who is usually considered the worst.
I am very fond of Swedish men, the Long Suffering Husband being of that background. And you’re absolutely right, they are un-macho, yet so very manly 🙂 A great combination. I loved the article on Alexander (sigh). Sexy and sweet!
i also haven’t met a Rochester i didn’t like 🙂 i like that story a lot and can always see it again. And yes i can see why that Alexander is so popular 🙂 I felt very close to both my friends, they gave the best friend-hugs ever! 🙂 Wish there was a different spark 😉 But it is nice to have such friends 🙂
Yes, I don’t think I have any male friends like that. It must be great!
I dipped into the book “Jane Eyre” the other day and was once again amazed by the modernity of Jane. She is so much her own person, fighting and struggling against a time that insisted she was nothing. As for Rochester, I always complain that women don’t see what a cruel, arrogant bastard he is. He’s a piece of work, but what redeems him is the fact that he loves Jane so deeply. And his sexual magnetism of course 🙂 The one thing he’s NOT is a handsome dreamboat. (Sigh) Not only can I not get enough of Rochester, I can’t stop talking about him…
Yes he is not the nicest of men; honestly looking at romantic leads Poldark is the best of all worlds. Too bad he is also a fairly young character 🙂
Ah, Ross Poldark. I need to watch the new one! In the old series, I got a little disgusted with him because he seemed very kind but also too gullible and naive for a Revolutionary War veteran.
Ah , well…. he was very very young when they shipped him off to fight. He comes back much less naive, though still impulsive. I loved the series as a whole and both his and Demelza’s character. If time you should watch it, it’s very entertaining. And there’s a pretty boy i don’t mind.
Fantastic. Think I would read Cold Comfort Farm (love, love that book and movie as well) or a food book. Too many to choose from. (I think in reality I would be too chicken. 😁)
Yes, I would be chicken too (or tofu, LOL). But I still like to ponder what my reading material of choice would be were I to take on this little project in private 🙂
I’d be happy to die laughing. As long as I don’t choke.
LOL. The magic wand goes on the other end 🙂
Interesting project…
Mmm …Magic wand (baguette magique – don’t ask for it in a bakery ^^)
I was seraching the origin of the expression “la petite mort” ( XVIe century)
and found out that there ‘s a movie called after the expression :
http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0166765/plotsummary
Baguette magique? That is hilarious!! I am extremely fond of food/sex metaphors, so I love it.
I see that I managed to get the gender of mort wrong. I will fix that! And thanks for the link.
Interesting post! I remember those videos from… back when they were first posted, I guess. I didn’t know about Toni Bentley’s book, though.
I second the Lelo recommendation. Freakin’ amazing… 🙂
No idea what I’d read. Maybe a great Canadian novel like Larry’s Party.
Just looked it up and it sounds like the kind of novel I enjoy 🙂
I’m not sure why Vanity Fair came so late to this particular party, but I’m glad they did, since I wouldn’t have known about it otherwise. Maybe I need to visit http://www.nerve.com more often!
What a way to start a lazy Sunday morning. In answer to a few comments about the distraction of reading while experiencing sexual pleasure ,and the odd circumstances, it seemed to me, and I liked this, that at least some of the readers were trying to stave off the orgasm, but to know success. This has opened up all sorts of possibilities. And did anyone else think it was hot just watching?
I agree! There is a pleasure in staving it off if you are confident of getting there in the end!
Oh, and let’s hear it for multiple orgasms!
Not something I have managed but maybe with lots of practice 😀
Pingback: Goth Cat | Linnet Moss